Introduction to the Protein Phenomenon
This transcript was generated using speech recognition software and has been reviewed by human transcribers, though it may still contain errors. For any quoting-related queries, please consult the episode’s audio or reach out to transcripts@nytimes.com.
From The New York Times, I’m Natalie Kitroeff, and this is “The Daily.” Today, we explore how protein has transformed into a national obsession, infiltrating every beverage, snack, and meal. Food writer Elizabeth Dunn joins us to discuss the evolution of this nutritional trend, examining whether the pursuit of protein has reached an excessive level. It’s Tuesday, August 26th.
The Ubiquity of Protein
Conversation Initiation
“Welcome to the show, Elizabeth,” Kitroeff begins.
Dunn responds, “Thanks for having me.”
Kitroeff continues, “Today, we’re diving into protein because, let’s face it, we are in the midst of a protein era. It’s everywhere, and we need to unpack how this phenomenon occurred.”
Shifting Focus in Food Writing
Dunn reflects on her 15 years of writing about food, stating, “For most of my career, my focus was on fine dining trends or celebrity chefs. Recently, it’s become apparent that these topics have less appeal. When I share that I write about food, people are more interested in discussing protein.”
Protein in Popular Culture
“If you scroll through your social media, like I do, you’ll find influencers promoting protein powders and sharing recipes. Protein-loaded products are everywhere in grocery and convenience stores,” Dunn explains.
She adds, “Research has shown that in the last decade, high-protein food and beverage products have quadrupled in number.”
The Historical Context of Protein Consumption
Understanding Protein
Kitroeff prompts Dunn to explain what protein is. “Protein is a macronutrient essential for our bodies, providing energy and aiding in tissue repair and muscle building,” Dunn elaborates.
She notes that historically, there was little concern for protein deficiency among the general population, except in cases of malnutrition or in developing regions.
Evolution of Protein Awareness
Dunn recounts, “In the 1950s, protein supplements were mainly marketed to bodybuilders. It wasn’t until the 1990s that protein gained widespread recognition.”
She identifies two key factors: the mainstream acceptance of fitness culture and the association between protein consumption and weight loss, particularly through diets like Atkins and South Beach.
“Even as those diet fads fade, interest in protein persists, notably surging during the pandemic as individuals focused more on health and wellness,” Dunn states.
Influencers and the Protein Movement
Emerging Influencers
Dunn highlights the rise of fitness influencers promoting protein-rich diets. “Individuals like Alex Clark, Andrew Huberman, and Peter Attia exemplify how protein is marketed as essential to achieving optimal health,” she remarks.
Huberman, a professor of neurobiology at Stanford, and Attia, a longevity-focused doctor, have significant followings, advocating for daily physical activity and high protein intake as pathways to health and longevity.
Protein Recommendations
The recommended dietary allowance for protein is 0.8 grams per kilogram of body weight. For a 150-pound individual, that translates to about 54 grams of protein, a target many can reach without deliberate effort. However, figures suggested by Huberman and Attia may require two to three times the ordinary intake.
Dunn notes, “The challenge lies in meeting the elevated protein requirements without exceeding calorie limits.”
Market Innovations: The David Bar
The Story Behind the David Bar
One notable innovation in the protein market is the David Bar, launched by Peter Rahal, who previously created the RXBAR. “After selling RXBAR for $600 million, Rahal aimed to develop a protein bar with the best protein-to-calorie ratio,” Dunn states.
He achieved this by minimizing non-protein calories and discovering EPG, a modified plant fat that offers significantly fewer calories than traditional fats.
Success and Growth
The David Bar was an instant hit, reportedly generating $1 million in sales within its first week, with expectations of reaching $180 million by 2025. Both Huberman and Attia have invested in the company, endorsing its revolutionary approach to protein consumption.
The Nutritional Debate
Is This Healthy?
As the trend continues, questions arise about the health implications of prioritizing protein. Dunn explains, “While excess protein isn’t harmful for most, it’s essential to consider which nutrients may be neglected in pursuit of a high-protein diet.”
She observes the growing popularity of ultra-processed foods, like the David Bar, despite an increasing skepticism surrounding such products.
The Joy of Protein Consumption
When asked about the appeal of protein-rich diets, Dunn remarks, “Many find joy in optimizing their eating habits, feeling that by consuming foods like the David Bar, they are moving closer to their ideal selves. It’s a community-driven lifestyle, with a strong identity tied to dietary choices.”
She concludes, “The enthusiasm over protein reflects a broader cultural shift, with many viewing their dietary commitments in almost spiritual terms, drawing parallels to religious devotion.”
Conclusion
“Thank you, Elizabeth, for sharing your insights,” Kitroeff wraps up.
Dunn replies, “Thanks, Natalie.”
